I am the most beautiful woman in the world.
Since beauty is subjective, believe it or not, the above
statement is true. It’s only true
according to Ted, but that doesn’t make any it less accurate.
It’s also true that there are many people who find my figure
repulsive and would sincerely beg not to have to see me in a swimsuit.
C’est la vie. As one
of my favorite drummers once said: “I prefer not to count the people that think
that I suck.”
Chances are that you, as a woman, have at some point in your
life seen a fellow woman somewhere and quietly, in some part of your psyche,
felt that you were either superior or inferior to her. You may have done this because she looked
homely to you, or was older or younger than you are, or had a face you thought
was pretty, or hair you found beautiful.
It is very likely that your brain regurgitated the chemical set to make
you feel this because she possessed either more or less body fat than you do.
You didn’t do this because you’re a bad person, you did this
because you’ve been conditioned to weigh and measure yourself against the
females of your species around you since the day you were born.
I have done this. I’m
about a hundred pounds overweight but it’s still easy enough to find a woman
who is bigger than me. On the flipside,
I’ve also seen women bigger than me and marveled over how beautiful they were,
but on occasion I have been guilty of thinking, before I could stop it: “whew…
at least I’m not that big.”
Maybe they weren’t carrying it in a way I thought looked good
or maybe they didn’t appeal to my particular beauty aesthetic. I can generally find something lovely about
most women, but I admit it’s not universal.
I automatically, with no ability to stop it, believe in some
part of my subconscious, that anyone thinner than me is also in a certain sense
– better. There are multiple reasons for this; the
first being that I’ve spent my life besieged by imagery of slender women as the
ideal and epitome of beauty. I can’t get
through a grocery store checkout without having to stare at ten different
magazine covers trying to tell me how I can lose weight, lose weight, lose more weight! More personally, since I’ve been struggling
to be thin since I was around fourteen, I see that thin women already have
something I’ve been working to obtain for well over half my life. Since they have achieved what I could not,
they must be better than I am. I suppose
that to my brain it’s like the obvious fact that someone with a Doctorate is
more educated than me, they know more.
Similarly someone thin has (in my subconscious) done more work and conquered
the gluttony that besieges me. They have
willpower, they have control, they are strong where I am weak. They are able to not eat.
To be honest with you, right now as I write this I am
feeling slight guilt for planning to have the audacity to not think upon myself as inferior to skinnier girls.
Human females have the exact reverse power dynamic to almost
every other animal species on the planet – the littlest of us is considered to
be the most powerful. I think this is
largely due to the fact that we live in a world where we no longer need to
defend ourselves physically in order to survive. A beauty aesthetic agreed upon by a
collective, rather than actual bodily prowess, determines our pecking order.
The reverse can also be true. There is a counter movement that praises the
curvier woman and demeans the slender. Although
this tactic is temptingly comforting to us heavy types, it still simply
reinforces the exact same belief that we’re superior or inferior to one another
based on nothing but the mostly arbitrary fact of how we look.
I don’t think men are the primary source of this problem. We’re all responsible as a society of course,
but in my experience it has rarely been men taking the reigns of this hate
show. When I have had fat taunts chanted
at me in grade school, when I have been ostracized from the rest of my group by
clothing stores, when I have read something on the internet or watched a news
report that spewed vitriol and ugliness about people like me, it has almost
always come from women. I firmly believe
that those women are regurgitating this filth (toward the slender and heavy
alike) because inside they truly do hate themselves more than anyone else.
That isn’t something to get angry or outraged over, that is
something to truly weep for.
As for men, despite my lifetime of being overweight, I have
never gone lonely for male attention when I desired it. Men (at least the ones I choose to hang out
with) seem to find my particularly lush figure as either erotic, adorable or
simply as okay as any other female figure because GIRL = GOOD!
I admit I do hang out with particularly cool guys. The guys who thought otherwise in my presence
have usually been kind enough to keep their opinions to themselves.
So why do women do this to each other? Not being a sociologist or a psychologist I
can only guess that it’s related to the same animal instinct that causes
mountain goats to butt heads and lions to try to eat one other – we have an
evolutionary instinct to be on top.
Humans though are much more than just our collection of blind instincts,
we can fight this.
My challenge to you is this: pay attention to it. When you feel yourself doing it - stop, and
gently reinforce the truth. No I am not
better, no I am not worse – we are all merely different.
We have to teach ourselves to be so much more than a blind
pecking order based on visual imagery.
We have to fight every day against our gut instinct to weigh and measure
ourselves on a value scale based entirely on a body that is only going to
wither and rot.
What about you will remain?
In some systems of belief, absolutely nothing - which leaves behind only
how you lived and treated yourself and others while you did it. For me, what is inside is eternal, but this
body will be so much dust in a mere eye blink of geological time. I have a responsibility to care for it while
it lives, but in the end of things it will not matter. Certainly how it looked on a beauty scale
decided by one small-minded and selfish culture will blow away like so much
chaff. I believe that if you can stop
finding yourself superior or inferior then you can also begin to stop hating
yourself as well.
I am not better, I am not worse. I am simply here.
Love this post. :') "To be honest with you, right now as I write this I am feeling slight guilt for planning to have the audacity to not think upon myself as inferior to skinnier girls." <-- Gah. Truth. Weep. Oh and yay Gustav quote! :D
ReplyDeleteThank you! And yay for you for recognizing the Gustav quote! Hee. *hugs*
DeleteI'm a little ashamed that I recognized the drummer quote but not the drummer. *hides*
ReplyDeleteCarolyn, this was beautiful, every bit as beautiful as you are. And you really touched a nerve—or whatever it was that made me get a little choked up, not because I think heinous thoughts about other women (generally), but because I incessantly think heinous thoughts about myself while I size myself up against other women! And now I find myself doing exactly what you said, "Well, at least my (insert whatever about myself I hate at the moment) isn't as bad as HERS," which leaves me struggling mightily to find some happy medium! *fist* I would just simply love to wake up one day and be TOTALLY OKAY with my impossibly stupid hair, my flabby thighs, and general hobbit-like features. Right now I can only dream of what I might be able to accomplish with the courage that that "TOTALLY OKAY" would bring into my life. But when in doubt, hopefully I'll remember to come back here and read Superior again. XOXO!